When it comes to installing posts for various applications, the decision between setting a post in the ground versus using an above-ground system can significantly affect durability, stability, and maintenance. This article will explore the pros and cons of both methods, helping you make an informed choice based on your specific needs.
Ground Set Posts
Description: Ground set posts are buried directly into the soil and secured with concrete.
Advantages:
-
Stability: Ground-set posts offer superior stability, especially for heavy loads. Their anchorage in the soil protects them from wind and accidental tipping.
- In terms of stability and load capacity, in-ground post have the advantage.
-
Aesthetics: With posts set firmly in the ground, the installation maintains a clean, professional look. The visible above-ground portion can be covered with dirt, concrete, wood...
-
Longevity: Properly installed ground-set posts can last for decades with little maintenance, particularly if treated for rot and pests.
-
Versatility: This method is suitable for a variety of applications, including fences, decks, signs, and more.
Disadvantages:
-
Labor Intensive: Digging post holes, mixing concrete, and waiting for it to cure can require more time and effort compared to above-ground installations.
- You will also have to make stilts in order to keep the post in place while the concrete sets. This takes more time and materials.
-
Soil Conditions: Installation success can depend on soil type and moisture levels. Rocky, sandy, or overly wet soil can complicate the process.
-
Maintenance Access: If the base deteriorates over time, repairs can be challenging, requiring excavation.
- This can be detrimental to a building. If hidden behind a wall (or underground) you may not know your posts are deteriorating until it is to late to fix them.
Above Ground Posts
Description: Above-ground posts are installed on concrete with brackets to secure and elevate them above the surface. This is commonly referred to as a post-mount or post-on-surface method.
Advantages:
-
Ease of Installation: Above-ground posts are generally easier and quicker to install. There’s no need to dig holes, making them ideal for temporary setups or in areas where digging is impractical.
- Another big advantage is being able to construct the entire wall on the ground before raising it all together or in sections.
-
Accessibility: Maintenance and repair are often simpler; the posts can be easily accessed without excavation, making replacement or adjustments less of a hassle.
-
Adaptability: Above-ground systems can be moved or reconfigured with relative ease, offering flexibility for changing needs.
Disadvantages:
- Stability: These posts may not hold up well against high winds or heavy loads, especially if not anchored securely to a solid structure.
-
Weather Exposure: Elevated posts are also susceptible to weather wear, such as rust or rot. Depending on how these are installed, this may not be a factor.
Conclusion
The choice between ground set and above-ground posts ultimately depends on the specific application, site conditions, and desired aesthetics. Ground set posts generally offer more stability and longevity, making them suitable for permanent installations, while above-ground posts provide ease of installation and maintenance, making them ideal for temporary or adaptable setups. By weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each method, you can select the right approach for your project, ensuring the best outcome and long-lasting satisfaction.
